Here’s the thing. I don’t really like pumpkin pie. I know it’s super traditional and you won’t find a Thanksgiving dessert table without it but as much as I try to get myself on board, I just can’t. I find traditional pumpkin pie one dimensional and mushy. It just doesn’t do it for me. Never has, never will. For as traditional as our Thanksgiving meal is- it’s the same every single year- dessert is a free for all. We switch it up each year making whatever sounds good. This year I’m leaning towards making banana cream and lemon meringue (I think) but there are so many amazing pies on this list that I’m sure I’ll change my mind a hundred more times! One things for sure: there won’t be a pumpkin pie on our table.

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

1. Apple Pear Praline Pie from Completely Delicious

2. Sweet Potato Pie with Pecan Topping from Simply Recipes

3. Classic Coconut Pie from Vintage Mixer

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Classic Coconut Cream Pie from Vintage Mixer

4. Chocolate Kahlua Pecan Pie from Chocolate Chocolate and More

5. No Bake Honey-Roasted Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie from Love and Olive Oil

6. S’mores Pie from A Southern Fairytale

7. Eggnog Brûlée Pie from Confessions of a Cookbook Queen

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Eggnog Brûlée Pie from Confessions of a Cookbook Queen

8. Fluffy Banana Cream Pie from Spicy Perspective

9. Snickerdoodle Pie from Mountain Mama Cooks

10. Blueberry Custard Pie from The Girl Who Ate Everything

11. Sweet Cherry Pie with Toasted Almonds from Sally’s Baking Addiction

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Sweet Cherry Pie with Toasted Almonds from Sally’s Baking Addiction

12. Raspberry Swirl Frozen Yogurt Pie from Cookin’ Canuck

13. Peach Bourbon Pie from Gimme Some Oven

14. Chocolate Honey Pie (Dairy Free) from Letty’s Kitchen

15. Sugar Wafer Chocolate Mousse Pie from Cookies and Cups

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Sugar Wafer Chocolate Mousse Pie from Cookies and Cups

16. Four Berry Pie from Foodie Crush

17. Apple Crumb Pie from Mountain Mama Cooks

18. Caramel Apple Crumble Pie from Averie Cooks

19. Maple Buttermilk Pie from 101 Cookbooks

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Four Berry Pie from FoodieCrush

20. Peanut Butter Pie from Handle the Heat

21. Buttermilk and Blackberry Pie from Spoon Fork Bacon

22. Salted Chocolate Caramel Tart from Brown Eyed Baker

23. Apple Ginger Hand Pies from Mountain Mama Cooks

25 Pie Recipes | mountainmamacooks.com

Apple Ginger Hand Pies from Mountain Mama Cooks

24. Cream Puff Pie from Cooking Classy

25. Cranberry Blueberry Pie from Completely Delicious

If you need any help in the pie crust department, go straight HERE. This is my go to recipe and the tutorial is spot on. I will say, however, that I usually forgo rolling the butter in by hand and just do it in the food processor. As long as you are careful not to over process, the crust will turn out flakey and delicious!

What are you serving for Thanksgiving this year? Do you have a favorite?

Pie Receipes feature

Connect with Mountain Mama Cooks on Pinterest, Facebook, and Twitter!

3 Responses to 25 Pie Recipes (that aren’t pumpkin!)

  1. Thanks for the link love. II can’t decide on which one of these I want to make for Thanksgiving. (Sweet potato pie has already been requested.)

  2. Melissa Brown says:

    I’m with you not really a fan of pumpkin, but one of my grandmother’s used to make a peach pecan pie that was wonderful!!

  3. Eunice says:

    This is tortuous for someone who is trying to be carb free for 4 weeks. I won’t get past 4 hours looking at these pies. My favourite thing to make and eat!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *